(08-07-2011, 05:45 AM)PJW Wrote: I think section a) was pretty well answered; clearly set out, relevant and of sensible length for the marks- in fact if anything some of the entries could have been slightly briefer to save a few moments.
Any answer can be criticised, but I think you'd be scoring close to the maximum marks for this bit.
Section b) explicitly required addressing 3 sub bullets and this element was also answered quite well, spoilt by having two entries for Quantified Risk Assessment due to a typo! Don't quite think you got the essential thing about CBA; it shouldn't be used for deciding what to do about safety risks- not at least in its "pure" form (explained more by inserted comment).
However I didn't feel that you did so well on the major part of "Describing how safety can be assured through the stages".
................
Section c)
TO BE CONCLUDED LATER
(03-07-2011, 04:14 PM)libracpy Wrote: As a first practice of Module 1 question, may I ask any comment of the answer if available.
Thank you very much.
Thank you very much for your valuable comment and feedback.
In fact, after review your comment about the answer, I think that I originally mis-understand the meaning of the question: {i.e. Describe how safety can be assured through each of these major stages.} The meaning of "EACH of these major stages" in my original mind is refer to "major stages in the project lifestyle", because the common wording - "major stages" is used. As a result, I use the table format for all 7 stages. However, I also think that it is not make sense for all 7 stages in practice as your view, and so I also have difficulty to answer this part of the question.
Besides of the content about the answer, may I ask one question about the skill of IRSE. Just use the above example and assume I have no better choice for other questions, if I have the difficulty to understand or answer this part of question, is it prefer to ignore this part of question, or try to answer which may be wrong.
Anyways, thanks again.